Insurance Company Contact Information

Whether you are looking for a new policy or want to file a claim, Donaghy Insurance Services can help you out! We offer competitive insurance rates from great companies and help you save by combining coverage from top insurers. 

Here are the contact details for service, claims, and billing assistance from insurance companies we represent.
Senior couple meeting with consultant

Emergency Claim Telephone Numbers and Direct Claim Contact Information

  • Aegis Insurance  
    • Claims: 800-233-2160
  • AmTrust / Technology Ins Co.
    • www.amtrustgroup.com/small-business-insurance
    • Claims: 877-528-7878
  • EMC / Employers Mutual Companies
    • www.emcins.com
    • 24-Hour claim reporting service at 888-EMC-CALL (888-362-2255)
  • First Insurance Funding
    • www.firstinsurancefunding.com
    • 800-728-7255
  • Foremost Insurance
    • www.foremost.com
    • Claims: 800-527-3907
    • Billing: 800-532-4221
  • Guard Insurance Group
    • www.guard.com
    • https://policyholder.guard.com
    • Customer Service: 800-673-2465
  • Harford Mutual / First Line National
    • Claims: 877-445-5826
    • www.harfordmutual.com
  • Harleysville
    • Claims: 800-892-8877
  • Hartford / Sentinel
    • www.thehartford.com
    • Claims: 800-327-3636
    • Billing / payment / service: 800-962-6170
  • Hartford Steam Boiler
    • www.hsb.com/HSBGroup
    • For service or claims: 1-800-472-1866
  • Liberty Mutual / OHIO Casualty / Excelsior / Peerless
    • Claims: 866-255-5530
    • Billing: 866-290-2920
  • Montour Mutual Insurance Co.
    • Claims: 570-387-1400
  • National General formerly GMAC
    • www.nationalgeneral.com
    • Claims / payments / service: 800-325-1088
  • National Grange Mutual / Main Street America
    • www.msagroup.com      
    • Claims: 877-425-2467
    • Pay by Phone 800-611-0958 Visa, MC, Discover or e-check, debit or check card
    • If you have problems call 888-333-4014 (8:30 AM - 9:00 PM) - live representative is available
  • State Workers Insurance Fund / SWIF
    • Billing: 570-963-4635
    • Claims: 888-388-7943
FREE, no-obligation consultations available!
Contact us today.
We work with leading insurance companies such as Liberty Mutual, The Hartford, and Progressive.
Hartford / Sentinel
Hartford / Sentinel
CLAIMS 800.327.3636
BILLING / PAYMENT / SERVICE 800-962-6170
Liberty Mutual
OHIO Casualty / Excelsior / Peerless
Claims: 866-255-5530
Billing: 866-290-2920
Progressive
PROGRESSIVE
CLAIMS / BILLING / PAYMENT / SERVICE
800-274-4499
EMC / Employers Mutual Companies
EMC / Employers Mutual Companies
24-Hour Claim Reporting service
888-EMC-CALL (888-362-2255)
Penn National Insurance
Penn National Insurance
Mobile / Online Help
800-766-2245, Option 5
Billing / payment: 800-766-2245
Claims: 800-766-2245  
If Workplace Injury: 800-374-4990
Harford Mutual / First Line National
Harford Mutual / First Line National
Claims: 877-445-5826
Guard Insurance Group
Guard Insurance Group 
Customer Service: 800-673-2465
National Grange Mutual / Main Street America
National Grange Mutual / Main Street America
Claims: 877-425-2467
Pay by Phone: 800-611-0958
Visa, MC, Discover,
E-check, debit / check card.
If you have problems, call:
888-333-4014
Live representative is available.
(8:30 AM - 9:00 PM)
Nazareth Mutual Insurance Co.
Nazareth Mutual Insurance Co.
Claims: 610-759-3020
SafeCo.
Safeco
Claims: 800-332-3226
Billing: 888-723-3260
Tuscarora Wayne (T-W) Insurance Co.
Tuscarora Wayne (T-W) Insurance Co.
Claims: 570-881-1127
Foremost Insurance
Foremost Insurance
Claims: 800-527-3907
Billing: 800-532-4221 
National General formerly GMAC
National General formerly GMAC
Claims / Payments / Service:
800-325-1088
AmTrust / Technology Ins Co.
AmTrust / Technology Ins Co.
Claims: 877-528-7878
Hartford Steam Boiler
Hartford Steam Boiler
For Service or Claims:
1-800-472-1866
Prime Rate Premium Finance
Prime Rate Premium Finance
800-777-7458
First Insurance Funding
First Insurance Funding
800-728-7255